
Claim A says Norfolk Island holds its own Thanksgiving. Claim B says Fiji adopted Thanksgiving from a shipwrecked Pilgrim. Claim A is true, and Claim B is completely made up.
Norfolk Island, a tiny Australian territory in the Pacific, is one of the few places outside North America that celebrates Thanksgiving, and it is the only one in Australia.
The tradition traces back to the 1890s and an American trader named Isaac Robinson. He settled on the island as an agent for Burns Philp & Co Ltd and later became its first and so far only US consul, though it is not certain the post was ever officially ratified.
American whalers called at Norfolk often, so Robinson proposed dressing up the church American-style. He and three friends tied palm leaves and lemons to the pews of All Saints Church.
Turkeys are not common on the island, so the feast is usually roast pork, chicken and bananas. Locals reportedly celebrate on the final Wednesday of November rather than the fourth Thursday, which in 2026 lands on today, November 25.
As for Claim B, no shipwrecked Pilgrim brought Thanksgiving to Fiji. The Norfolk Island tradition grew out of the American whaling trade and Robinson's church decorations.
Think you'd have guessed it? Share this with a friend who loves a holiday curveball and see if they can beat you.














