
Claim A says Nixon ate four helpings of cranberries to calm a 1959 panic. Claim B says Mamie Eisenhower served lobster to avoid cranberries. Claim A is true, and Claim B is completely made up.
On November 9, 1959, just before Thanksgiving, Health, Education, and Welfare Secretary Arthur Flemming warned the public that some cranberries from Oregon and Washington carried traces of a weedkiller called amino triazole. Within hours, grocery stores across the country pulled cranberry products from their shelves.
The cranberry industry was in crisis, so politicians turned to showmanship. Vice President Richard Nixon made headlines by eating four helpings of cranberries at an event in Wisconsin, a major cranberry-growing state. John F. Kennedy drank a tall glass of cranberry juice, then asked for a second.
The First Lady's table told a different story. Mamie Eisenhower claimed she had served cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving, but guest Rosalind Russell let slip that she was served applesauce instead.
The damage was real. Fresh cranberry sales fell by 73%, and Congress eventually paid the industry nearly $10 million in compensation. By the next year, sales were back to normal.
Claim B is wrong because the Eisenhowers did not swap in lobster. The substitute at that Thanksgiving table was applesauce.
Think you'd have picked the right one? Share this with a friend and see if they get fooled too.














