
Claim A says NYC kids once begged in rags on Thanksgiving. Claim B says NYC kids once trick-or-treated in tuxedos on Easter. Claim A is true, and Claim B is completely made up.
The custom was called Ragamuffin Day. Children in New York City dressed in oversized, tattered clothes, parodying beggars in the style of Chaplin's "Tramp," and knocked on neighbors' doors.
Their line was "Anything for Thanksgiving?" The reward was usually pennies, an apple or a bit of candy. A 1909 newspaper article dated the tradition to around 1870, though even that paper called its origins "dubious."
Officials were not amused. In 1930, the city's schools superintendent sent a circular declaring that "modernity is incompatible" with children masquerading and pestering adults. In 1937, a boys club began holding parades to lure kids away, and by 1940 its parade drew over 400 children under the slogan "American boys do not beg."
The strangest arrest came in 1943, when a 25-year-old man was picked up for wearing women's clothing over his Army trousers. His wife told the magistrate he was dressed for a Thanksgiving Ragamuffin party. The last mention of the parades is from 1956, as the Macy's parade took over the holiday spotlight.
As for Claim B, there is no record of New York children trick-or-treating in tuxedos on Easter. The costumed begging tradition belonged to Thanksgiving, and it was ragged clothes, not formalwear.
Think you'd have spotted the real one? Share this with a friend and see if they'd have guessed right.














