
In late November 2005, the retail group Shop.org put out a press release announcing a new shopping event. It had a catchy name, a tidy backstory, and a bold claim attached to it.
The group is the online arm of the National Retail Federation. Days earlier, staff had brainstormed names for the Monday after Thanksgiving, and they tossed out Black Monday, Blue Monday and Green Monday before landing on one.
The winner was "Cyber Monday." The release called it "one of the biggest online shopping days of the year," and the New York Times ran the standard explanation: workers browsing on speedy office internet.
There was a problem with that. Shop.org's own executive director, Scott Silverman, admitted in 2005, "It's not the biggest day." ComScore data placed it only 12th on the list of biggest online shopping days.
The name is usually credited to Ellen Davis, though Silverman has named Davis, Ray Greenly and himself as involved. The claim rested on 2004 research, and it didn't match what the numbers showed.
Then the label did its work. Wikipedia lists US sales of $608 million in 2006 and $1.028 billion in 2010, and Silverman says it hit No. 1 around 2010, calling it "definitely a self-fulfilling prophecy."
Today Adobe calls it the biggest online shopping day of all time, with one 2025 comparison putting US sales at $14.25 billion. A slogan that overstated the facts ended up creating them.














