Candy canes and peppermint go together like Christmas and snow, right? Except peppermint wasn't the original flavor, wasn't traditional, and only became "the" candy cane flavor because of a supplier's mistake in the 1920s. Everything you think you know about this holiday classic is based on an accident.
The first candy canes appeared in Germany around 1670 – and they weren't mint flavored. They weren't even flavored at all. They were just plain white sugar sticks that a choirmaster gave to children to keep them quiet during long Christmas services. The hook shape supposedly represented a shepherd's crook, linking them to the nativity story.
For over 200 years, candy canes remained plain, white, and unflavored. When they came to America in the 1800s, they were still just sugar sticks. Some candy makers started adding stripes and various flavors – wintergreen was actually more common than peppermint.
Then in 1919, a candy maker named Bob McCormack in Albany, Georgia, started mass-producing candy canes by hand. His brother-in-law, a Catholic priest named Gregory Keller, even invented a machine in the 1950s to automate the process of twisting and bending them into their distinctive shape.
Here's where the accident happened: McCormack's main flavoring supplier made a mistake on a large order in the early 1920s. Instead of sending the usual mix of flavors, they sent an enormous shipment of peppermint flavoring by mistake – way more than McCormack could use for anything else.
Rather than waste it or send it back, McCormack decided to use it all in his candy canes. The peppermint candy canes were a hit, partly because peppermint was associated with Christmas through other holiday candies and partly because the strong minty flavor simply stood out.
But here's the kicker: other candy makers saw McCormack's success and assumed peppermint was the "traditional" flavor. They started copying him, and within a few decades, peppermint became so dominant that people forgot candy canes ever came in other flavors.
By the 1950s and 60s, peppermint candy canes were everywhere, and the idea that they'd always been mint became accepted as fact. The accident had completely rewritten history.
Today, about 90% of candy canes sold are peppermint flavored, and most people have no idea that this "tradition" is less than 100 years old and started with a shipping error.
So next time you're eating a peppermint candy cane and thinking about cherished Christmas traditions, remember: you're actually tasting the result of a 1920s logistics mistake that became so popular it erased centuries of actual tradition. That "authentic" flavor is pure accident.