Trending Now

The Colony That Outlawed Christmas

The Colony That Outlawed Christmas

One of these claims about a colonial-era Christmas crackdown is true, and one is completely made up. Can you guess which one really happened?

Read more
The Boss's Computer Built Cyber Monday

The Boss's Computer Built Cyber Monday

In 2005, a shopping holiday leaned on one workplace perk. Guess which.

Read more
The Year Thanksgiving Split the Country

The Year Thanksgiving Split the Country

One of these claims about a presidential Thanksgiving feud is true, and one isn't. Can you guess which story really happened?

Read more
The Sled Test That Gave Pessimism Its Name

The Sled Test That Gave Pessimism Its Name

A famous saying about things going wrong began in a desert lab. The story is messier than you'd guess.

Read more
The White House Thanksgiving Raccoon Story

The White House Thanksgiving Raccoon Story

One of these claims about a Thanksgiving gift to a president's family is true, and one is made up. Can you guess which one really happened?

Read more
See All Content
logo
  • Sports

  • History

  • Language

  • Food

  • Tech

  • Animals

  • Sports
  • History
  • Language
  • Food
  • Tech
  • Animals
  • ​
Food FactsFun Facts

Red Dye No. 3 - Banned Then Not Banned

Red candy illustration

In 1990, the FDA banned a synthetic food dye called Red Dye No. 3 from all cosmetics and topical drugs. The reason? Studies showed it caused cancer in laboratory animals. At the time, the FDA said they would "take steps" to ban it from food too.

Then they just... didn't. For 34 years, Red Dye No. 3 remained perfectly legal in candy, cakes, cookies, cherry products, and thousands of other foods that children and adults eat every day.

Think about that for a second. The FDA determined this dye was too dangerous to put in your lipstick, but totally fine to put in your kid's candy. You couldn't rub it on your lips, but you could absolutely eat it.

The evidence against Red Dye No. 3 wasn't new or controversial. Animal studies from the 1980s showed it caused thyroid tumors in rats. The National Toxicology Program called the evidence "convincing." Based on this, the FDA banned it from cosmetics in 1990 under the Delaney Clause – a law that prohibits any additive shown to cause cancer in humans or animals.

But here's where it gets weird: Red Dye No. 3 had already been permanently approved for food use back in 1969, before the cancer studies came out. By the time the FDA banned it from cosmetics in 1990, removing it from the food supply would have required a whole separate regulatory process.

So the FDA took the path of least resistance. They banned it where it was easier to ban (cosmetics) and promised they'd get around to banning it from food eventually. Then they sat on that promise for more than three decades.

Meanwhile, food manufacturers kept using Red Dye No. 3 in thousands of products. Conversation hearts, candy corn, fruit cocktails with those bright red cherries, certain medications, cake frostings – all legally contained a dye that the FDA had already determined causes cancer in animals.

The food industry argued that the levels in food were safe, that the rat studies didn't apply to humans, and that there was a threshold below which the dye was harmless. But the Delaney Clause doesn't care about thresholds or industry arguments. If it causes cancer in animals, it's banned. Period.

So why did Red Dye No. 3 stay in food for 34 years? In 2022, the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), along with 23 other organizations and scientists, filed a petition demanding the FDA finally ban it from food. They essentially had to force the FDA to follow its own law.

Even then, the FDA didn't act immediately. It took over two years for them to respond to the petition. Meanwhile, California got tired of waiting and passed its own law in 2023 banning Red Dye No. 3 from food sold in the state starting in 2027.

Finally, in January 2025 – 35 years after promising to do so – the FDA banned Red Dye No. 3 from food and ingested drugs. Food manufacturers have until January 2027 to reformulate their products. Drug manufacturers have until January 2028.

The really frustrating part? Other countries banned Red Dye No. 3 from food years ago. Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and China all prohibit it. Food companies already make versions of their products without Red Dye No. 3 for those markets. They just kept selling the version with the cancer-causing dye to Americans because they legally could.

So for 34 years, the FDA allowed a known carcinogen to stay in the food supply – not because the science changed, not because it was suddenly safe, but because removing it required regulatory effort they didn't want to make until consumer groups and state legislation forced their hand.

The next time you see a bright red candy or maraschino cherry, remember: that color was deemed too dangerous for lipstick in 1990, but perfectly fine for you to eat until 2025.

Related Content

History Facts

Fun Facts

10 November 2026

Post

A Hostage Waits at the Palace Whenever the King Visits

Every year, a politician is held at a palace so the monarch comes home safe. Here's why....

History Facts

Fun Facts

10 November 2026

Post

The Strange Story of Gunpowder and Pigeon Droppings

One of these claims about England's old gunpowder-and-pigeon-dung business is true, and one isn't. Can you guess which one really happened?...

History Facts

Fun Facts

10 November 2026

Post

Viagra Facts: A Heart Drug, Blue Vision and Hamsters

Why Viagra began as a heart drug, how it can tint your vision blue and why the FAA cares, and the hamster jet lag study that won an Ig Nobel Prize....

History Facts

Fun Facts

09 November 2026

Post

Cannibalism: 3 True Stories You Won't Believe

Which state bans cannibalism, why the CDC warned about placenta pills, and how a tribe's funeral ritual may have left a gene that fights brain disease....

History Facts

Fun Facts

09 November 2026

Post

The Laughing Sickness That Shut Down Schools

In 1962, three schoolgirls started laughing and a whole region couldn't stop. Nobody was joking....

History Facts

Fun Facts

09 November 2026

Post

The Surprising Origin of the Movie Trailer

One of these claims about the first movie trailer is true, and one is completely made up. Can you guess which one really happened?...

Language Facts

Fun Facts

08 November 2026

Post

Your Latte Art Is Named After a Monk's Hood

A Sunday coffee order shares its name with a monk's wardrobe and a monkey. Here's the link....

Tech Facts

Fun Facts

08 November 2026

Post

How NASA Sends Tools to Astronauts in Orbit

One of these claims about NASA and tools for astronauts is true, and one is completely made up. Can you guess which one really happened?...

History Facts

Fun Facts

08 November 2026

Post

Tattoos: The Iceman, Ink in Your Nodes (+1 More)

Ötzi's 5,300-year-old tattoos, where your tattoo ink really travels in your body, and the company that frames a dead loved one's actual tattooed skin....

History Facts

Fun Facts

07 November 2026

Post

The Taboo Word That Broke Through Ad Breaks

One of these claims about a taboo word in a 1980s TV commercial is true, and one is completely made up. Can you guess which one really happened?...

Sports Facts

Fun Facts

07 November 2026

Post

Why a Marathon Is Exactly 26.2 Miles Long

The odd number behind every marathon traces back to one summer day in London. Here's how it happened....

History Facts

Fun Facts

07 November 2026

Post

Starbucks Secrets: Pequod, the CIA and Fecal Ice

The Moby-Dick name Starbucks almost used, the secret store inside CIA headquarters and the 2017 UK investigation that found fecal bacteria in coffee shop ice....

History Facts

Fun Facts

06 November 2026

Post

Lobotomies: 3 True Stories That Sound Made Up

How lobotomies won a Nobel Prize, why a 12-year-old was operated on for being a kid, and the secret Kennedy family surgery that was hidden for decades....

Food

Fun Facts

06 November 2026

Post

The Curious Case of How Spam Got Its Name

One of these claims about how Spam got its name is true, and one is completely made up. Can you guess which one really happened?...

Language Facts

Fun Facts

06 November 2026

Post

A Frustrated Author, a Word List, and a Hat

A famous children's book began as a publisher's headache. The author hated the assignment....
Terms and ConditionsDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationPrivacy PolicyPrivacy NoticeAccessibility NoticeUnsubscribe
Copyright © 2026 Fun Fact Feed